Welcome to the Amish Cheese Shop.

We invite you to browse through our store and shop with confidence. We invite you to create an account with us if you like, or shop as a guest. Either way, your shopping cart will be active until you leave the store.

Thank you for visiting!

Our Amish cheeses are artisan cheeses made from milk collected from Amish farms.  The cows are not fed artificial hormones or additives and the herds average 40 head instead of 400 or more in the large factory farms.  This is the only milk used in our Amish cheeses.

Most cheeses are cut from blocks, cutting exact weights are difficult but we try our best to cut as ordered. Please allow a 10% plus or minus differental to the weight.  Our cheese comes to you cut fresh not prepackaged. Thank you!

Shop by Category

     
    3 Year Aged Yellow Sharp Cheddar 1lb5 Year Aged Yellow Sharp Cheddar 1lb6 Year Aged Sharp Yellow Cheddar 1lb

    $13.50

    $15.00

    $17.00

    Amish butter cheese 1lb
    7 Year aged sharp white cheddar 1lb9 year aged white cheddar 1lb Amish butter cheese 1lb

    $19.00

    $21.00

    $13.00

    Amish Cream Butter 5lb Unsalted Log Amish Cream Cheese 8 oz.
    Amish Cheese - 1 lb. block - Bacon flavoredAmish Cream Butter 5lb Unsalted LogAmish Cream Cheese 8 oz.

    $13.00

    $26.40

    $4.25

    Amish Jalapeno 1lb Amish Milk Can Cheddar 1lb
    Amish Full Cream Butter 2 lb RollAmish Jalapeno 1lbAmish Milk Can Cheddar 1lb

    $10.25

    $13.00

    $13.00

    Amish Roll Butter 10oz Slice Apple Butter 8 oz.
    Amish Roll Butter 10oz SliceApple Butter 8 oz.Apple Butter BBQ Sauce

    $4.59

    $5.25

    $6.50

    Apricot Jam 16 oz. Apricot Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice Ball Park Salt 4.5 oz
    Apricot Jam 16 oz.Apricot Jam 16 oz. Natural JuiceBall Park Salt 4.5 oz

    $6.89

    $7.99

    $4.49

    Beef Summer Sausage Sm Log/lbs Bermuda Onion Black Cherry Jam 16 oz.
    Beef Summer Sausage Sm Log/lbsBermuda OnionBlack Cherry Jam 16 oz.

    $9.00

    $12.25

    $6.89

    Black Raspberry Jam 16 oz. Black Raspberry Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice Black Valley Extra Sharp per lb
    Black Raspberry Jam 16 oz.Black Raspberry Jam 16 oz. Natural JuiceBlack Valley Extra Sharp per lb

    $7.49

    $9.05

    $12.75

    Blackberry Butter 8 oz. Blueberry Butter 8 oz. Buttery Topping 16 oz.
    Blackberry Butter 8 oz.Blueberry Butter 8 oz.Buttery Topping 16 oz.

    $5.25

    $5.25

    $4.45

    Caramel Glaze 16 oz. Cherry Butter 8 oz. Cherry Jam 16 oz
    Caramel Glaze 16 oz.Cherry Butter 8 oz.Cherry Jam 16 oz

    $4.45

    $5.25

    $6.89

    Cherry Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice Colby White
    Cherry Jam 16 oz. Natural JuiceColby WhiteColby Yellow

    $8.09

    $12.00

    $10.50

    Corn Relish 16 oz. Danish Blue Cheese Danish Dill Havarti.
    Corn Relish 16 oz.Danish Blue Cheese Danish Dill Havarti.

    $6.99

    $21.75

    $15.00

    Danish Havarti Dutch Apple Jam 16 oz. Farmer's Cheese
    Danish Havarti Dutch Apple Jam 16 oz.Farmer's Cheese

    $14.50

    $6.89

    $13.00

    Fiesta Jack Cheese Fig Jam 16 oz. Fig Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice
    Fiesta Jack CheeseFig Jam 16 oz.Fig Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice

    $13.00

    $6.89

    $8.45

    Firehouse FROG Jam 16 oz. Full Cream
    FirehouseFROG Jam 16 oz.Full Cream

    $10.50

    $6.89

    $14.00

    German Bologna Sm Log/lbs Gooseberry Jam 16 oz. Gouda
    German Bologna Sm Log/lbsGooseberry Jam 16 oz.Gouda

    $7.89

    $6.89

    $13.00

    Gourmet Baby White 1 lbs Gourmet Baby White 2 lbs Gourmet Baby White 6 lbs
    Gourmet Baby White 1 lbsGourmet Baby White 2 lbsGourmet Baby White 6 lbs

    $3.99

    $5.75

    $15.00

    Gourmet Baby Yellow 1 lbs Gourmet Baby Yellow 2 lbs Gourmet Baby Yellow 6 lbs
    Gourmet Baby Yellow 1 lbsGourmet Baby Yellow 2 lbsGourmet Baby Yellow 6 lbs

    $3.99

    $5.49

    $9.99

    Gourmet Lady Finger 1 lbs Gourmet Lady Finger 2 lbs Gourmet Midnight Blue 1 lbs
    Gourmet Lady Finger 1 lbsGourmet Lady Finger 2 lbsGourmet Midnight Blue 1 lbs

    $3.99

    $6.49

    $3.99

    Gourmet Midnight Blue 2 lbs Gourmet Midnight Blue 6 lbs Gourmet Purple 1 lbs
    Gourmet Midnight Blue 2 lbsGourmet Midnight Blue 6 lbsGourmet Purple 1 lbs

    $6.75

    $18.00

    $3.99

    Gourmet Purple 2 lbs Gourmet Purple 6 lbs Gourmet Rainbow 1 lbs
    Gourmet Purple 2 lbsGourmet Purple 6 lbsGourmet Rainbow 1 lbs

    $6.75

    $18.00

    $3.99

    Gourmet Rainbow 2 lbs Gourmet Rainbow 6 lbs Gourmet Red 1 lbs
    Gourmet Rainbow 2 lbsGourmet Rainbow 6 lbsGourmet Red 1 lbs

    $6.49

    $15.00

    $3.94

    Gourmet Red 2 lbs Gourmet Red 6 lbs Green Tomato Relish 16 oz.
    Gourmet Red 2 lbsGourmet Red 6 lbsGreen Tomato Relish 16 oz.

    $6.39

    $15.00

    $6.89

    Guggisberg Baby Swiss Heini's Baby Swiss
    Guggisberg Baby Swisshabenaro cheddarHeini's Baby Swiss

    $13.50

    $14.50

    $13.00

    Heini's Lacy Baby Swiss Herb and Garlic
    Heini's Lacy Baby SwissHerb and Garlichoney with the comb

    $13.50

    $13.50

    $9.49

    Horseradish Cheddar Hot Green Tomato Relish 16 oz.
    Hoppin F-R-O-G Jam 16ozHorseradish CheddarHot Green Tomato Relish 16 oz.

    $6.89

    $14.00

    $6.89

    Hot Pepper Jam 16 oz. Hot Pickled Okra 16 oz. Hot Southern Chow Chow 16 oz.
    Hot Pepper Jam 16 oz.Hot Pickled Okra 16 oz.Hot Southern Chow Chow 16 oz.

    $6.89

    $6.99

    $6.99

    Jalapeno Yogurt Cheese Limberger 8 oz. Low Fat Low Sodium Lorraine Swiss
    Jalapeno Yogurt CheeseLimberger 8 oz.Low Fat Low Sodium Lorraine Swiss

    $13.00

    $9.99

    $13.00

    Mild Pickled Okra 16 oz. Mild Southern Chow Chow 16 oz.
    Mild Pickled Okra 16 oz.Mild Southern Chow Chow 16 oz.Mustard Eggs 32oz

    $6.99

    $6.99

    $8.25

    Old Fashion Yellow Popcorn/2lb Old Fashion Yellow/ 6 lbs
    Old Fashion Yellow Popcorn/2lbOld Fashion Yellow/ 6 lbsoriginal yogurt

    $6.00

    $15.00

    $14.00

    Peach Butter 8 oz. Peach Pecan Jam 16 oz. Peach Pineapple 16 oz.
    Peach Butter 8 oz.Peach Pecan Jam 16 oz.Peach Pineapple 16 oz.

    $5.25

    $6.89

    $6.89

    Pear Jam 16 oz. Pear Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice Pepper Bacon/2lb
    Pear Jam 16 oz.Pear Jam 16 oz. Natural JuicePepper Bacon/2lb

    $6.89

    $8.60

    $15.00

    Pickled Baby Beets 16 oz. Pickled Dilly Corn 16 oz. Plum Butter 8 oz.
    Pickled Baby Beets 16 oz.Pickled Dilly Corn 16 oz.Plum Butter 8 oz.

    $6.99

    $6.99

    $5.25

    Pumpkin Butter 8 oz. Red Raspberry Jam 16 oz. Red Raspberry Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice
    Pumpkin Butter 8 oz.Red Raspberry Jam 16 oz.Red Raspberry Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice

    $4.89

    $6.89

    $8.86

    Red Sweet Pepper Relish 16 oz. Sampler Box
    Red Sweet Pepper Relish 16 oz.Rihms Thick Sliced Bacon/2lbSampler Box

    $6.99

    $15.00

    $14.99

    Sausage Sampler Sharp White Cheddar
    Sausage SamplerSeasoned Veggie ChipsSharp White Cheddar

    $24.00

    $6.29

    $13.50

    Sharp Yellow Cheddar Smoked  Bermuda Onion Smoked Amish Gouda
    Sharp Yellow CheddarSmoked Bermuda OnionSmoked Amish Gouda

    $13.50

    $14.00

    $14.00

    Smoked Bacon Smoked Bermuda Onion Smoked Cheddar
    Smoked BaconSmoked Bermuda OnionSmoked Cheddar

    $14.00

    $14.00

    $14.00

    Smoked Colby Smoked Horseradish Smoked Mozzerella
    Smoked ColbySmoked HorseradishSmoked Mozzerella

    $14.00

    $14.00

    $14.00

    Smoked Natural Swiss Smoked Provolone Smoked Swiss
    Smoked Natural SwissSmoked ProvoloneSmoked Swiss

    $14.00

    $14.00

    $14.00

    Strawberry Butter 8 oz. Strawberry Jalapeno Jam 16 oz. Strawberry Jam 16 oz.
    Strawberry Butter 8 oz.Strawberry Jalapeno Jam 16 oz.Strawberry Jam 16 oz.

    $5.25

    $6.89

    $6.89

    Strawberry Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice Strawberry Rhubarb Butter 8 oz. Strawberry Rhubarb Jam 16 oz
    Strawberry Jam 16 oz. Natural JuiceStrawberry Rhubarb Butter 8 oz.Strawberry Rhubarb Jam 16 oz

    $8.05

    $5.25

    $6.89

    Strawberry/Rhubarb Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice Sugar River Beef Sticks /lb Sweet Garlic Dill 16 oz.
    Strawberry/Rhubarb Jam 16 oz. Natural JuiceSugar River Beef Sticks /lbSweet Garlic Dill 16 oz.

    $8.05

    $8.50

    $6.99

    Sweet Hot Habanero 16 oz. Swiss 'n' Rye (processed) Tomato and Basil Yogurt
    Sweet Hot Habanero 16 oz.Swiss 'n' Rye (processed)Tomato and Basil Yogurt

    $6.99

    $10.50

    $13.50

    Tomato Garlic Yogurt Tomato Jam 16 oz. Triple Berry Jam 16 oz.
    Tomato Garlic YogurtTomato Jam 16 oz.Triple Berry Jam 16 oz.

    $13.50

    $6.89

    $6.89

    Triple Berry Jam 16 oz. Natural Juice Vegetable Yogurt Venison/Pork Sausage Lg Log/lbs
    Triple Berry Jam 16 oz. Natural JuiceVegetable YogurtVenison/Pork Sausage Lg Log/lbs

    $8.05

    $13.50

    $15.00

    Venison/Pork Sausage Sm Log/lbs Vidalia Onion Zesty Bread and Butter Pickles 16 oz.
    Venison/Pork Sausage Sm Log/lbsVidalia OnionZesty Bread and Butter Pickles 16 oz.

    $7.98

    $13.00

    $6.99